Why so Few Church Age Prophecies?
Donald Cameron
Why are there no prophecies in the Bible about the fall of Rome, the Dark Ages, the Reformation, the Spanish Inquisition, the Pogroms, the Holocaust, nuclear warfare, space exploration and so forth? Understandably people ask such questions out of genuine interest, rather than idle curiosity. They know that the Old Testament provided prophecies for Israel of two thousand years ago, regarding the Lord’s First Coming, even if those were ignored by the religious hierarchy. Why, they ask, does the New Testament not provide us with answers about our age? It has plenty of prophecies about what is still future, they say, but not what is present.
The short answer is, that had we needed to know, we would have been told. But we should be able to give a fuller answer. The Book of Acts is one of the most important in the Bible regarding fulfilled prophecy. Let us think back to that well-known passage in chapter 1: “Therefore, when they had come together, they asked Him, saying, ‘Lord, will You at this time restore the kingdom to Israel?’” (v 6). It was a serious question, asked by the disciples who were aware that such a restoration was prophesied. Significantly, Jesus did not correct their perception. But that restoration lay long beyond their lifetimes and was safe in the Father’s hands: “And He said to them, ‘It is not for you to know times or seasons which the Father has put in His own authority.’” (v 7). Many, many generations later, there are to be those who will understand and experience that about which their predecessors had enquired.
Then in the Acts narrative comes one of the great ‘buts’ of Scripture – a but which introduces a different prophecy, a prophecy with its own timescale - two “you shalls”: “But you shall receive power when the Holy Spirit has come upon you; and you shall be witnesses to Me in Jerusalem, and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the end of the earth.” (v 8). The first “you shall” was to be fulfilled ten days later; the second is still being fulfilled. What a magnificent commission! But how little detail is given about the timetable of this about-to-be-born Church Age. Never let us underestimate the importance of the Church Age compared to other dispensations, just because so little is prophesied for it.
The danger is that we leave it at that, and forget about prophecy altogether. But that is not how God wants it to be; steps were immediately taken by Him to counter this possibility: “Now when He had spoken these things, while they watched, He was taken up, and a cloud received Him out of their sight. And while they looked steadfastly toward heaven as He went up, behold, two men stood by them in white apparel, who also said, ’Men of Galilee, why do you stand gazing up into heaven? This same Jesus, who was taken up from you into heaven, will so come in like manner as you saw Him go into heaven’” (vv 9-11). That was not the time to be gazing upwards, when there was a massive programme to occupy them before He comes back. Even today, we have work to get on with, but we should be gazing up as we labour, because the signs of the times demand it: “Now when these things begin to happen, look up and lift up your heads, because your redemption draws near” (Luke 21:28).
The Old Testament contains massive prophetic evidence of Christ’s identity when He came unto His own to be despised, rejected and crucified, and being raised from the dead. The Book of Acts, from the Day of Pentecost on, makes exemplary use of these Old Testament prophecies when convincingly preaching the Gospel to the Jews both in Jerusalem and on the missionary journeys. It is also utterly appropriate that there should be many prophecies in the Old Testament concerning Him and His reign during this old world’s final chapter, when He will be vindicated and glorified, having made His enemies His footstool, before ruling with a rod of iron. It is only in retrospect that the two sets of prophecies can be distinguished.
There are some comparatively short term prophecies in the book of Acts. In chapter 11 we read of a prophecy given by the Holy Spirit through Agabus to the church at Antioch, warning of a great famine during the reign of Claudius Caesar.
At Ephesus, Paul told the church leaders that God had revealed to him that chains and tribulation awaited him. He told the flock, which he was about to leave behind at Ephesus, that they were to be subjected to attacks of savage wolves (20:29). Paul’s ill-treatment at Jerusalem had also been foretold (21:10-14). Whatever conclusions we may come to regarding Paul’s refusal to be dissuaded from going to Jerusalem, we must conclude that ultimately, Paul was acting within God’s will, because later, whilst in refuge in the Caesarea garrison, the Lord stood by him (23:11) and told him that he was to witness for Him in Rome. In the meantime Paul was able to preach to kings, governors and the Jewish religious hierarchy, saying nothing other than what Moses and the prophets said would happen regarding Christ’s death and resurrection, the first from the dead, and proclaim light to both Jews and Gentiles (26:2-3).
We do find a latter day prophecy in Paul’s address to the Athenians at the Areopagus: “Truly, these times of ignorance God overlooked, but now commands all men everywhere to repent (the Church Age), because He has appointed a day on which He will judge the world in righteousness by the Man whom He has ordained” (Acts 17:30-31).
Neither in the Old, nor the New Testament, are there prophecies regarding events between the writing of the Book of Revelation and the Rapture, other than general, warnings of the latter falling away, apostasy and prophetic disinterest as the Second Coming draws near. Virtually the whole Church Age, from the 70 AD sack of Rome, is in a prophetic vacuum, with nothing specific to which to look forward other than the Rapture. That blessed hope should satisfy us.
It is thought by many, including myself, that the seven little epistles in Revelation chapters 2 and 3, as well as applying to the little congregations themselves, represent or reflect the progress of the Church from the time Revelation was written, about 96 AD, to the Rapture. It is an unpopular theory among Post-Millennialists, because they do not like to see themselves as represented by Laodicea, the church which was lukewarm - neither cold nor hot; the church which thought it was rich and had need of nothing. But these are not themselves prophecies about events in the Church Age.
There are thus very few Church Age prophecies beyond those early ones already fulfilled. Over many decades I have constantly been brought back to that injunction in Matthew’s and Mark’s accounts of the Olivet Discourse, “Let the reader understand”. Until we investigate the circumstances of the Abomination of Desolation, to which Jesus had just referred, we will not be able to understand that, following the Church Age, there is to be that seven year period of Tribulation, between the Rapture and the Coming in Power. This is very familiar to our regular readers; I do not propose to enlarge upon it here, except to emphasise that, following around two millennia of almost no specific prophesied events, there is to be a short period on earth in which everything in Revelation chapters 4 to 19 is to be fulfilled – a whole host of prophecies for the Day of Vengeance of our God (Isaiah 61:2). They have to be fulfilled in order that Christ, whom the heavens received at His ascension, may return to accomplish the restoration of all things foretold by the prophets: “Whom heaven must receive until the times of restoration of all things, which God has spoken by the mouth of all His holy prophets since the world began.” (Acts 3:21). In that single verse we have the timing of the Millennium confirmed. Were A-Millennialists and Post-Millennialists to ponder further those words, and obey the injunction to understand in Matthew 24:15 and Mark 13:14, they might all become Pre-Tribulationists, and share our blessed hope!
Nearly all the prophecies of the Millennium are found in the Old, rather than the New Testament. Why? Because it is in the Millennium that Israel will be the head and not the tail of the nations. It is to Jerusalem that the nations are to come to worship. The restored environment, after the disastrous ravages of the Tribulation, deserves and receives wonderful descriptive prophecies which should be taken literally. But the Church, resurrected or Raptured, will by then be in the holy city, the New
Jerusalem, and so will not require further prophecies.
Around the start of the last century there was a movement called ‘Historicist Pre-Millennialism’ - historicist, not historical. Here I am paraphrasing from my 2006 book, Apocalypse Facts and Fantasies. The leading proponent of Historicism was Grattan Guinness. His book: ‘The Approaching End Of The Age’, was first published in 1894 and very widely circulated. It is a massive and complex tome. It claims to be Pre-Millennial, but is strongly anti-futurist. Indeed, his 1897 edition contains a lengthy appendix recording answers to the numerous Futurist objections raised against his previous editions.
This movement taught that the Book of Revelation was a sort of encoded description of evolving church history. I have devoted a section to the movement in my book, ‘The Blessed Hope of Pre-Tribulationism’. 1 It revived the teaching of Joseph Mede in 1627, which had been elaborated by others. By the early 19th Century, important predicted dates and identifications had been proved false, though nothing significant having happened then.
My old pastor, J Sidlow Baxter, quotes Dr Joseph Angus’s note on the multiplicity of Historicist solutions, which can emerge from this subjective and almost random system of establishing some sort of relationship between prophecy and Church Age events. Dr Angus wrote: “Where Elliot sees in the sixth seal a reference to Constantine, Faber sees allusion to the first French Revolution; where Bengel sees in the star fallen from heaven a good angel, Elliot discerns Mohammed; the scorpion locusts that have power for five months mean to Mede one hundred and fifty years of the dominion of the Saracen, but to Vitringa they mean Goths, and to Scherzer Jesuits. All this seems to be arbitrary and hazardous in the extreme.” 2
What more or less killed off Historicism, was the fact that, having in their system come virtually to the Lord’s Return in Revelation 19, they had run out of further prophecies to link to the numerous major events of the 20th Century.
Guinness at least had the excuse, which no believer today can offer, that there were only limited signs of a Jewish nation state in his day. However, a year after his 1897 edition, from which the above quotes are taken, the first Zionist Congress took place in Lausanne. That was a major nail in the Historicist coffin!
1. Cameron, Donald CB. The Blessed Hope of Pre-Tribulationism, Crimond House, Newtownards, 2021, pp 94-100.
2. Angus, Joseph, cited by J Sidlow Baxter in Explore The Book, vol 6, Marshall, Morgan & Scott, London & Edinburgh, 1955, p 338.
Also in this edition:
From The Editor - Richard Salmon.
Food for Thought - Richard Salmon.
Blow a Trumpet in Zion - Josh Schwartz.
Why so Few Church Age Prophesies? - Donald CB Cameron.
Signs of The Times - Tony Pearce.
No Time For Complacency - Jonathan Brentner.
Shadows of Things to Come - Tom Gilbreath.
Spotlight on Israel - Tony Pearce
Six Reasons Why Every Christian Should Desire The Soon Return of Jesus - Dr. David Reagan.
Will We Recognise Each Other in The Resurrection? - John Williams.
Uncertain Times? Not at All - Jan Markell.
Church listings - ‘What’s On?’
Tract Of The Month.